Our Rule of Law and Congressional Oversight

New York County Lawyers Association image on Rule of Law and Congressional Overs.
statement-letter

Our Rule of Law and Congressional Oversight

Portrait of NYCLA President in professional attire.
Written by: Ronald C. Minkoff, NYCLA President
Published On: Nov 19, 2026

 

The New York County Lawyers Association’s (NYCLA) President Ronald C. Minkoff issued this statement on the Rule of Law and Congressional Oversight.

It is clear that there will be a number of oversight investigations by committees of the incoming 120th Congress. Several members of Congress have expressed great enthusiasm at the effects the investigation process will have on their intended targets. The Trump administration has already begun to oppose those investigations aggressively. As President of The New York County Lawyers Association (NYCLA), I believe both reactions are inappropriate, and that it would be useful to set forth three basic Rule of Law principles that should govern Congressional oversight investigations.

First, it is a fundamental requirement of the Rule of Law that members of Congress fulfill their Constitutional duty to see that federal laws are faithfully executed by conducting oversight investigations of the President, members of his administration, and others. As 2 U.S.C. § 190d states, “each standing committee of the Senate and the House of Representatives shall review and study, on a continuing basis, the application, administration, and execution of those laws … the subject matter of which is within the jurisdiction of that committee.” See generally Watkins v. United States, 354 U.S. 178, 187 (1957) (“The power of the Congress to conduct investigations is inherent in the legislative process. That power is broad. . . . It comprehends probes into departments of the Federal Government to expose corruption, inefficiency or waste.”).

Second, the Rule of Law requires that all Congressional investigations be conducted with due concern for the rights of all parties. In particular, members of Congress who are or may be members of investigative committees should not prejudge the results of those investigations. Moreover, the committees should recognize the applicable due process rights of those being investigated. The Supreme Court outlined those rights when it overturned a criminal conviction for contempt of Congress of a witness who refused to answer certain questions posed by the House of Representatives’ Committee on Un-American Activities. Watkins, 354 U.S. at 207-210.

Third, the Rule of Law generally protects members of Congress from criminal charges for their participation in congressional investigations. This is achieved by our Constitution’s Speech and Debate Clause, Article I, Section 6, clause 1, which declares that members of Congress shall not “be questioned in any other place” for “any Speech or Debate in either House.” The Supreme Court described the significance of this provision in the course of discussing an earlier decision, Kilbourn v. Thompson, 103 U.S. 168 (1881), in which the Court found that Congress lacked the power to arrest a person for contempt of Congress, but that none of the members was liable for false imprisonment:

The legislative privilege, protecting against possible prosecution by an unfriendly executive and conviction by a hostile judiciary, is one manifestation of the “practical security” for ensuring the independence of the legislature.  United States v. Johnson, 383 U.S. 169, 179 (1965)

Thus, there is little basis for the White House Counsel or other federal law enforcement officials to suggest that Congress members participating in oversight hearings may be committing a federal crime.

Congressional committee investigations are an important tool to be used for assuring the American people that any administration follows the Rule of Law. I urge the Administration to cease its threats of criminal sanctions against committee members. I urge all investigating committees and their members to follow the Rule of Law by seeking and conducting such investigations with due concern for the rights of all parties. Thus, the Administration and the committees can vigorously disagree on an investigation while working together to implement one of the most basic features of the Rule of Law, having a means to expeditiously determine whether our laws are being faithfully executed, and if not, suggesting how to better execute those laws.

# # #

This statement has been issued by the NYCLA President. It has not been reviewed by NYCLA‘s full Board of Directors and does not necessarily represent its views.