NYCLA Supports the Catalyst Theory for NYS EAJA Fees in the New York State Court of Appeals

View Full Amicus Brief Here

 

JaAPL-2026-00027
New York County Clerk’s Index No. 154613/2022
Appellate Division–First Department Case No. 2024-02497



Court of Appeals

of the

State of New York


LUCIA JAQUEZ,

– against –

Petitioner-Respondent,

 

DANIEL TIETZ, as Commissioner of the New York State Office of Temporary and Disability Assistance,

Respondent-Appellant,

– and –

GARY JENKINS, as Commissioner of the New York City Human Resources Administration,

Respondent.



BRIEF FOR AMICI CURIAE NEW YORK CITY BAR ASSOCIATION, NEW YORK COUNTY LAWYERS ASSOCIATION, THE NEW YORK STATE BAR ASSOCIATION AND THE LOUIS STEIN CENTER FOR LAW AND ETHICS AT FORDHAM UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF LAW IN SUPPORT OF PETITIONER-RESPONDENT



Orrick Herrington & Sutcliffe LLP
Attorneys for Amici Curiae
51 West 52nd Street

New York, New York 10019
Tel.: (212) 506-5000
Fax: (212) 506-5151
rkathawala@orrick.com
mrshapiro@orrick.com

Date Completed: September 28, 2026



CORPORATE DISCLOSURE STATEMENT

Pursuant to Rule 500.1(f) of the Rules of Practice of the Court of Appeals of the State of New York, the amici curiae state as follows:

New York City Bar Association states that it is a not-for-profit corporation and thus has no parents, subsidiaries, or affiliates.

New York County Lawyers Association states that it is a not-for-profit corporation and thus has no parents, subsidiaries, or affiliates.

New York State Bar Association states that it is a not-for-profit corporation and thus has no parents, subsidiaries, or affiliates.

Louis Stein Center for Law and Ethics at Fordham University School of Law states that it is part of a not-for-profit corporation and thus has no parents, subsidiaries, or affiliates.

STATEMENT OF RELATED LITIGATION

Pursuant to Rule 500.13(a) of the Rules of Practice of the Court of Appeals of the State of New York, the amici curiae state that, as of the date of the completion of this Brief, there is no related litigation pending before any court.

Table of Contents

Page 

1:  Statement of Interest

4:  Question Presented

4:  Summary of Argument

8:  Argument

  • 8:  New York has a long and abiding commitment to reducing the power imbalance between low-income residents and the government bureaucracies charged with providing them with services and support

  • 10:  The need for low-income competent counsel to represent low-income new Yorkers persists

  • 12:  Recognition of the Catalyst Theory ensures the EAJA services as a bulwark in access to justice

  • 17:  The Catalyst Theory promotes broader Societal Benefits

    • 18:  Erroneous decision-making has devastating impacts on underserved communities

    • 20:  Erroneous decision making is a drain on the public fisc

    • 21:  The Catalyst Theory saves resources by incentivizing better and more efficient administrative decisions

    • 22:  The Catalyst Theory promotes the values of the New York State Bar

25:  Conclusion